What Do We Do With Halloween?

Published October 20, 2025
Colorful autumn maple leaves

Halloween. That time of year when the air turns crisp, the leaves fall, and the stores explode with costumes, candy, and spider webs that somehow never come down afterward. Most everywhere I go, there are a few jack-o’-lanterns and decorations up. Lately, I’ve had several conversations with people who are wrestling with what to do with Halloween. Some are asking questions about its history. Others are sensing the Lord leading their families to make different decisions about participating.

My daughter has had some questions come up, too. So I thought maybe more people are thinking about this than I realized, and perhaps we could benefit from working through it together. My wife, Sherry, and I were in Asheville this weekend, and outside the mall was a huge tent set up as a Halloween store. It got me thinking about just how much this holiday has become part of our culture.

In a quick search this morning, I found that according to the National Retail Federation, Americans were projected to spend a record $13.1 billion on Halloween in 2025. That’s up from $11.6 billion in 2024. That’s a lot of candy and costumes! With Halloween having such a big presence in our culture, I think it’s worth asking how we should approach it as followers of Jesus.

Some Christians have decided to steer clear of Halloween altogether. Others see it as harmless fun or a great opportunity to connect with neighbors. I know godly people on both sides of that conversation.

So what’s the right thing to do? Or perhaps a better question is, what’s the wise thing to do?

Before we get there, let’s look at where all of this came from.

Where Did Halloween Come From?

The history of Halloween is actually a little more complicated than I realized. The name Halloween comes from “All Hallows’ Eve,” the evening before All Saints’ Day, when Christians remembered those who had gone before them in the faith, including martyrs who gave their lives for Christ. But there is another part of the story. In parts of Ireland and Scotland, older traditions were connected to a Gaelic festival called Samhain. It marked the end of the harvest season and the beginning of winter.

Some traditions associated that time of year with spirits, the dead, and supernatural activity. There were customs involving disguises, fires, and attempts to predict the future. You’ve probably heard that people dressed up to hide from wandering spirits or left treats outside to keep them away. Those explanations are often repeated as the origins of our modern costumes and trick-or-treating.

But here’s something I found interesting. Historians aren’t nearly as certain about those connections as we sometimes make them sound. Many of the customs we recognize today developed much later. There was “souling,” when people went from house to house seeking food in connection with prayers for the dead. There was also “guising,” especially in Scotland and Ireland, when people dressed in costumes and went door to door, sometimes performing songs or jokes in exchange for treats.

And then there were the carved turnips! In Ireland and Scotland, people carved faces into turnips, sometimes associated with frightening away spirits. When the custom came to America, pumpkins proved much easier to carve. I’m pretty thankful for that one!

By the ninth century, November 1 had become widely established in Western Christianity as All Saints’ Day. Some have suggested that the church intentionally placed the celebration there to replace pagan observances. That may have played a role, but historians debate whether that was actually the reason. Interestingly, October 31 is also Reformation Day. On that date in 1517, Martin Luther is traditionally understood to have posted his 95 Theses, helping spark the Protestant Reformation.

As Irish and Scottish immigrants brought their traditions to America, especially during the 1800s, Halloween gradually developed into something much closer to what we recognize today. By the twentieth century, costumes, candy, neighborhood activities, and eventually movies and commercial entertainment had helped shape the holiday. So Halloween didn’t come from one single tradition. Its history includes Christian observances, older folk customs, and a lot of cultural changes over the centuries.

And I think it’s important that we are accurate about that. I’ve heard some very strong claims about Halloween’s history from Christians who sincerely want to honor the Lord. Some of those claims are difficult to establish from the surviving evidence. A connection to Samhain does not prove that every costume or piece of candy began as an occult ritual. And recognizing Christian observances in Halloween’s history does not make everything associated with the holiday today good. The Colson Center’s Breakpoint article challenges some of the dramatic origin stories, and the Library of Congress’s American Folklife Center explains why even the familiar claim that Samhain was the Celtic New Year needs care.

Knowing the history helps us speak truthfully, but it doesn’t settle every question about how we should participate today. Scripture must guide our judgments about the actual practices before us.

What About Halloween Today?

I can remember dressing up as Superman when I was a kid. I had a cape, and I’m pretty sure I believed I could fly when I ran through the yard wearing it. I wasn’t thinking about ancient Celtic traditions or anything spiritual. I was thinking about Superman and getting candy! Maybe you have similar memories. Sherry and I were talking recently about how much Halloween decorations have changed. People are going all in with enormous skeletons, frightening figures, and elaborate displays in their yards.

Some of it is funny and creative. Some of it, quite frankly, is disturbing. Even in places advertised as family-friendly, I’ve noticed costumes and decorations that are extremely frightening or inappropriate. Then we see those same things shared all over social media. And that raises a question for me. Just because something has become normal in our culture, does that mean it’s something we should embrace as Christians? Of course not.

But we also need to be careful about assuming that everything associated with Halloween is automatically sinful. A child wearing a Superman costume and collecting candy is not doing the same thing as someone practicing witchcraft or attempting to communicate with the dead. Those are very different things, and I think Scripture helps us make those distinctions.

Here’s something that bothers me, though. I understand that a child dressed as Superman isn’t practicing witchcraft. But I also look around and wonder why we’ve become so comfortable celebrating things that God calls evil.

Some displays go beyond being silly or spooky. They glorify demonic imagery, cruelty, violence, and evil. Romans 12:9 tells us to abhor what is evil and cling to what is good. That doesn’t make every skeleton or costume sinful. It does give us reason to ask: What are we learning to laugh at, celebrate, and enjoy?

Parents, our children are learning from what we allow, what we laugh at, and what we celebrate. Philippians 4:8 calls us to dwell on what is true, honorable, right, pure, lovely, and worthy of praise. A product being marketed to children does not remove our responsibility to exercise discernment.

Sometimes saying no isn’t legalism. Sometimes it’s a parent trying to shepherd a child’s heart.

As followers of Jesus, we are called to honor Him in every area of life. October 31 doesn’t give us permission to set aside our convictions, compromise our witness, or participate in things that dishonor Christ.

But neither should we create commandments for other believers where God has not given them.

That’s where we need wisdom.

So What Should We Do?

Before we consider these approaches, I want to say something to families who have decided not to participate. I don’t think you’re being unreasonable. When you see the celebration of darkness, fascination with the occult, and some of the things being marketed to children, I understand why you would say, “That’s not something I want my family involved in.”

There are good biblical reasons to take those concerns seriously. At the same time, I don’t believe Scripture requires us to conclude that every costume, every piece of candy, or every neighborhood gathering is sinful. We need both conviction and grace.

I’ve talked with Christians I deeply respect who have come to different conclusions about Halloween. Here are four approaches worth considering.

1. Abstain for the Sake of Conviction

Some families decide to skip Halloween entirely. They don’t want their children exposed to the darker elements of the holiday, and they believe the wisest decision for their family is simply not to participate. A couple of our church families have shared with me that this is where they’ve landed. I respect that. If you’ve prayed about it, searched the Scriptures, and believe this is what honors the Lord for your family, then follow that conviction.

And parents, use it as an opportunity to disciple your children. Explain why you’re making that decision. Help them understand that following Jesus sometimes means choosing differently from the people around us.

Just be careful that your family’s conviction doesn’t become a standard by which you judge every other Christian family.

2. Redeem the Opportunity and Do Something Different

Other families and churches choose to host events that provide a fun alternative to Halloween. They may have games, candy, food, and opportunities to build relationships without embracing the darker themes associated with the holiday. I think there’s something good about that. We want our children to have fun. We want to create memories. We want to love people and welcome families. And what an opportunity to point people to Jesus!

I love the thought of creating environments where families can enjoy being together and where people who might never attend a worship service can begin building relationships with believers. Of course, having an alternative event doesn’t automatically make it spiritual. Our purpose should be more than simply providing another place to get candy. We want people to experience the love of Christ through us and, when opportunities come, hear the good news of Jesus.

3. Engage With Purpose

Some Christians decide that Halloween provides one of the best opportunities of the year to meet their neighbors. Think about it. How many nights of the year do families willingly walk up to your front door? You don’t have to decorate your porch with cobwebs and skeletons to show kindness. You can turn on the porch light, hand out some really good candy, learn a few names, and have conversations with people in your neighborhood.

Maybe you even find an opportunity to invite someone to church or share what Jesus has done in your life. You don’t have to force a gospel conversation into every interaction. Just love people genuinely and be ready when God opens a door. Sometimes a simple act of kindness can begin a relationship that gives you opportunities to share Christ later.

4. Dress Up and Trick-or-Treat With Discernment

Some Christian families choose to participate more fully. Their children dress up, walk through the neighborhood, and enjoy the evening together. They believe costumes and candy can be innocent fun when approached with biblical discernment. I think we need to be careful before declaring that every family who makes this decision is compromising their faith. But discernment matters.

What are the costumes celebrating? What are we exposing our children to? Are we making light of things Scripture calls evil? Are we choosing things that are appropriate and honoring to Christ? A funny costume or a superhero cape is one thing. Glorifying occult practices, sexual immorality, or cruelty is another. If you choose to participate, think carefully about what you’re allowing and what you’re teaching your children through those choices.

And don’t miss the opportunity to enjoy time together as a family and show kindness to your neighbors.

What Does the Bible Say?

This is where I want us to spend some time, because our decisions as believers shouldn’t ultimately be driven by culture, tradition, or even our personal preferences. They should be shaped by the Word of God. The Bible doesn’t give us a verse that says, “Thou shalt not celebrate Halloween.” But it does give us clear commands and principles that help us think through these questions.

1. We Must Reject What God Calls Evil

1 Thessalonians 5:22 tells us to “abstain from every form of evil.” Romans 12:9 says, “Abhor what is evil; cling to what is good.” And Romans 12:21 reminds us, “Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good.” Those are clear commands. As Christians, we don’t get to redefine evil simply because something has become popular or entertaining. Scripture specifically condemns sorcery, divination, spiritism, and attempts to communicate with the dead (Deuteronomy 18:9–14).

Those practices are not harmless spiritual experiments. And Paul tells believers in 1 Corinthians 10:14 to flee from idolatry. Later in that chapter, he makes clear that participating in pagan worship is not something Christians can treat as spiritually neutral. We should take those warnings seriously. But notice something important.

The Bible tells us to abstain from evil, not merely from everything that someone might associate with evil.

That’s an important distinction. We need to be able to identify what Scripture actually condemns rather than assuming that every costume, pumpkin, or piece of candy carries the same spiritual significance.

2. Christian Freedom Must Be Guided by Wisdom

I love what Paul says in 1 Corinthians 10:23:

“All things are lawful, but not all things are profitable. All things are lawful, but not all things edify.”

Paul is talking about the proper use of Christian freedom, particularly in a setting where believers were navigating questions about food associated with idol worship. His point is that being free to do something doesn’t automatically mean it’s the best thing to do. That’s worth remembering. Sometimes our first question is, “What’s wrong with it?” But maybe we should also be asking, “What’s good about it?” Will this help me honor Christ? Will it benefit my family? Will it strengthen my witness? Is it wise?

Paul gives us a guiding principle just a few verses later. 1 Corinthians 10:31 says:

“Whether, then, you eat or drink or whatever you do, do all to the glory of God.”

Whatever you do. That includes the decisions we make about Halloween. I think that’s a much better starting point than simply asking how much we can participate in without crossing a line.

Christian freedom is freedom to live for Jesus.

Across 1 Corinthians 8–10, Paul asks whether our choices are beneficial, whether they build others up, whether they involve idolatry, and whether they glorify God. A clear conscience matters, but it does not make something God forbids acceptable.

Sometimes a mature use of freedom is choosing to give up something we could otherwise enjoy. We can do that because we love Jesus and our neighbors, without trying to earn God’s favor or requiring every Christian to make the same choice.

3. Our Freedom Must Be Governed by Love

This is where 1 Corinthians 8 becomes especially helpful. The believers in Corinth were wrestling with whether they could eat food that had been offered to idols. Some understood that an idol was nothing and that the food itself was not spiritually changed by being offered to a false god. Others had backgrounds in idol worship, and eating that food still carried a very different meaning for them.

Paul’s concern was that one believer might exercise his freedom in a way that encouraged another believer to violate his conscience. And he gives this powerful statement in verse 13:

“Therefore, if food causes my brother to stumble, I will never eat meat again, so that I will not cause my brother to stumble.”

Think about that. Paul was willing to surrender something he was free to enjoy if doing so would protect a brother or sister in Christ.

The principle is simple: Love should govern how we use our freedom.

That doesn’t mean every time someone disagrees with our decision, we are automatically sinning. Causing someone to stumble is more serious than simply doing something another person doesn’t prefer. Paul’s concern is that our actions might lead another believer into sin or against his conscience. But it does mean we should care deeply about how our decisions affect others. If my freedom is encouraging someone else to compromise, love should cause me to reconsider.

And if another believer chooses not to participate in something I feel free to enjoy, I shouldn’t pressure them to join me. That’s love, too.

4. We Must Respect the Conscience of Other Believers

Romans 14 may be one of the most helpful chapters for this entire conversation. Paul addresses disagreements among believers about food and the observance of certain days. Some believers felt free to eat certain foods. Others did not. Some regarded one day above another, while others considered every day alike. Paul tells them in Romans 14:5:

“Each person must be fully convinced in his own mind.”

Then in verse 6, he explains that believers should seek to honor the Lord in what they do. And later, in verse 12, he reminds us:

“So then each one of us will give an account of himself to God.”

Now, Romans 14 isn’t permission to ignore clear biblical commands. Paul isn’t saying that something God calls sin becomes acceptable if we feel comfortable doing it. He’s addressing matters where Scripture allows believers to make different decisions before the Lord. And that’s where I believe much of the Halloween conversation belongs. Not every part of Halloween is morally neutral. Some activities clearly violate Scripture.

But other decisions, like handing out candy, wearing an innocent costume, or choosing not to participate at all, may be matters of conscience and wisdom. And Romans 14 tells us something we all need to hear. The person who participates shouldn’t look down on the person who abstains. And the person who abstains shouldn’t condemn the person who participates. Both need to answer to the Lord. I think we could all use a little more of that kind of humility.

But What About Spiritual Darkness?

I don’t want to skip over this, because I know it’s one of the concerns many Christian families have. Spiritual darkness is real. Ephesians 6:12 reminds us that our struggle is not against flesh and blood but against spiritual forces of wickedness. Peter warns us that the devil is our adversary and tells us to remain alert (1 Peter 5:8). We should never become casual about sin, occult practices, or the spiritual battles Scripture describes.

And I do think it’s worth considering how much our culture has come to celebrate things that are frightening, violent, or openly associated with evil. Something doesn’t automatically become wholesome just because someone labels it entertainment. Parents, we need to pay attention to what our children are watching, what they’re wearing, and what we’re teaching them to enjoy. But here’s the other side of that truth. We don’t have to live in fear.

Colossians 2:15 tells us that through the cross, Christ triumphed over the rulers and authorities. Jesus has won the decisive victory, even as we continue to resist the devil and stand firm in faith. A pumpkin doesn’t have spiritual power over your home. A piece of candy isn’t something you need to fear because of the date on the calendar. We should neither dismiss the reality of spiritual evil nor become superstitious about ordinary things.

That confidence also helps us take spiritual concerns seriously. Deuteronomy 18:9–14 forbids occult practices, and 1 Corinthians 10:14–22 warns against participating in idolatrous worship. Depicting something and participating in it are different, but actual involvement in divination, sorcery, or attempts to communicate with the dead is not a matter of Christian liberty.

Ephesians 5:8–11 calls believers to walk as children of light and refuse participation in the unfruitful deeds of darkness. We should never become fascinated with what God tells us to reject. We do not need to live in fear of darkness, and we should not celebrate evil.

Our confidence is in Jesus Christ.

And our responsibility is to walk in obedience to Him.

A Few Questions Worth Asking

Parents, I would encourage you to take some time to pray and talk through these things together. And honestly, these are good questions for all of us, whether we have children at home or not.

  • What does Scripture clearly say about what I’m considering?
  • Am I participating in something God calls evil, or am I dealing with a matter of personal conviction?
  • What am I teaching my children through this decision?
  • Can I do this with a clear conscience before the Lord?
  • Will this build up my family and help me love my neighbors?
  • Can I honestly say that what I’m doing is for the glory of God?

And perhaps one more question.

Am I extending the same grace to other believers that I would want them to extend to me?

I’ve been thinking about that one personally. Recently, in a conversation about an entirely different topic, I realized that there have been times when I’ve allowed my personal convictions to become commandments for other people. Or at least I’ve looked at someone else’s decisions with a little judgment in my heart. I hate to admit that, but it’s true. And I don’t want to do that. I want to be faithful to Scripture. I want to be clear where God is clear. I want to warn people about things that are genuinely sinful.

But I also want to be careful not to bind someone’s conscience where Scripture has left room for freedom. That’s a balance we all need to work toward.

So Where Do We Land?

Maybe your family will decide to stay home, turn off the porch light, and spend the evening doing something entirely different. Maybe you’ll participate in a church event. Maybe you’ll have the best candy on the street and get to know a few neighbors. Or maybe your kids will be walking through the neighborhood dressed as superheroes, and you’ll be trying to keep them from eating all their candy before you get home.

Whatever you decide, I hope you’ll make that decision prayerfully, with an open Bible and a desire to honor Jesus. And let’s remember something. The most important question about our lives is whether we belong to Jesus Christ.

Where Scripture speaks clearly, we must obey. Where Scripture allows freedom, we must exercise wisdom. Where believers differ in those matters, we must show grace.

Our hope isn’t found in avoiding a holiday, making the right cultural decisions, or being more careful than the family down the street. Our hope is in Jesus, who died for our sins, rose from the grave, and offers forgiveness and eternal life to everyone who repents and believes in Him. Because of Christ, we don’t have to live in fear of darkness. And because we belong to Him, we should want every part of our lives to reflect His holiness and love.

So whether you’re wearing a Superman cape or turning off the porch light, remember the words of 1 Corinthians 10:31:

“…whatever you do, do all to the glory of God.”

May we be people who love God’s Word, listen carefully to His truth, love one another well, and seek to honor Christ in every decision we make. And may we give one another grace in the places where faithful believers may come to different conclusions.

For Further Thought

If you’d like to keep thinking through this with your family, these Christian voices emphasize different aspects of the decision:

I don’t agree with every historical detail or recommendation in these resources. I share them because each can help us think carefully, return to Scripture, and speak graciously with families who make different decisions.

By His grace,

Pastor Jason